How did your MP vote on conscience issues?
About Conscience Votes
Conscience votes are not a comprehensive measure of a politician's values. They are usually only held on sensitive questions of life, and do not apply to other important value matters where politicians usually follow their party's line. Nonetheless, conscience votes do show how a politician approaches a significant ethical question, where their sense of values comes from, and what their personal view is on what we believe to be one of the most important questions of all: the protection of human life from conception to natural death.
Listed below is how your MP voted on a number of important Bills brought before Parliament.
How did your local Member vote?
Research Involving Human Embryos and Prohibition of Human Cloning Amendment Act 2007 – voting record (11 Oct 2007). Despite this Bill's misleading title, it allows human embryos to be cloned and then killed for research purposes.
Summary of votes: | Electorate | Party | MP | Cloning vote | Emily’s List |
| Mount Ommaney |
ALP |
Attwood, Mrs Julie |
Opposed |
|
| Aspley |
ALP |
Barry, Ms Veronica |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| South Brisbane |
ALP |
Bligh, Hon Ms Anna |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Chatsworth |
ALP |
Bombolas, Mr Chris |
Supported |
|
| Cairns |
ALP |
Boyle, Hon Ms Desley |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Capalaba |
ALP |
Choi, Mr Michael |
Opposed |
|
| Cunningham |
LNP |
Copeland, Mr Stuart |
Opposed |
|
| Hinchinbrook |
LNP |
Cripps, Mr Andrew |
Opposed |
|
| Broadwater |
ALP |
Croft, Ms Peta-Kaye |
Supported |
|
| Gladstone |
IND |
Cunningham, Mrs Elizabeth |
Opposed |
|
| Sandgate |
ALP |
Darling, Ms Vicky |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Bundaberg |
LNP |
Dempsey, Mr John |
Opposed |
|
| Kawana |
LNP |
Dickson, Mr Steven |
Supported |
|
| Noosa |
LNP |
Elmes, Mr Glen |
Opposed |
|
| Redlands |
ALP |
English, Mr John |
Absent |
|
| Greenslopes |
ALP |
Fenlon, Mr Gary |
Supported |
|
| Yeerongpilly |
ALP |
Finn, Mr Simon |
Supported |
|
| Moggill |
LNP |
Flegg, Dr Bruce |
Opposed |
|
| Maryborough |
IND |
Foley, Mr Christopher |
Opposed |
|
| Mount Coot-tha |
ALP |
Fraser, Hon Andrew |
Supported |
|
| Gympie |
LNP |
Gibson, Mr David |
Opposed |
|
| Brisbane Central |
ALP |
Grace, Ms Grace |
[Elected after vote] |
|
| Gaven |
ALP |
Gray, Mr Philip |
Supported |
|
| Kallangur |
ALP |
Hayward, Hon Kenneth |
Supported |
|
| Stafford |
ALP |
Hinchliffe, Mr Stirling |
Supported |
|
| Warrego |
LNP |
Hobbs, Mr Howard |
Supported |
|
| Keppel |
ALP |
Hoolihan, Paul |
Supported |
|
| Darling Downs |
LNP |
Hopper, Mr Raymond |
Opposed |
|
| Toowoomba South |
LNP |
Horan, Mr Michael |
Opposed |
|
| Whitsunday |
ALP |
Jarratt, Ms Janice |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Gregory |
LNP |
Johnson, Mr Vaughan |
Opposed |
|
| Ashgrove |
ALP |
Jones, Ms Kate |
Supported |
|
| Albert |
ALP |
Keech, Hon Mrs Margaret |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Mount Isa |
ALP |
Kiernan, Mrs Betty |
Opposed |
|
| Charters Towers |
LNP |
Knuth, Mr Shane |
Opposed |
|
| Surfers Paradise |
LNP |
Langbroek, Mr John-Paul |
Supported |
|
| Kurwongbah |
ALP |
Lavarch, Mrs Linda |
Supported |
|
| Southport |
ALP |
Lawlor, Mr Peter |
Supported |
|
| Indooroopilly |
GRN |
Lee, Mr Ronan |
Opposed |
|
| Tablelands |
ONP |
Lee Long, Ms Rosa |
Opposed |
|
| Beaudesert |
LNP |
Lingard, Hon Kevin |
Supported |
|
| Lytton |
ALP |
Lucas, Hon Paul |
Opposed |
|
| Glass House |
ALP |
Male, Ms Carolyn |
Supported |
|
| Mirani |
LNP |
Malone, Mr George |
Opposed |
|
| Caloundra |
LNP |
McArdle, Mr Mark |
Opposed |
|
| Hervey Bay |
ALP |
McNamara, Hon Andrew |
Supported |
|
| Burdekin |
LNP |
Menkens, Mrs Rosemary |
Opposed |
|
| Burnett |
LNP |
Messenger, Mr Robert |
Opposed |
|
| Logan |
ALP |
Mickel, Hon John |
Opposed |
|
| Bundamba |
ALP |
Miller, Mrs Jo-Ann |
Opposed |
Yes (2006) |
| Waterford |
ALP |
Moorhead, Mr Evan |
Supported |
|
| Mackay |
ALP |
Mulherin, Hon Timothy |
Absent |
|
| Mundingburra |
ALP |
Nelson-Carr, Hon Ms Lindel |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Clayfield |
LNP |
Nicholls, Mr Timothy |
Supported |
|
| Ipswich |
ALP |
Nolan, Ms Rachel |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Cook |
ALP |
O'Brien, Mr Jason |
Supported |
|
| Inala |
ALP |
Palaszczuk, Ms Annastacia |
Supported |
|
| Fitzroy |
ALP |
Pearce, Mr James |
Supported |
|
| Mulgrave |
ALP |
Pitt, Hon Frederick |
Opposed |
|
| Nanango |
IND |
Pratt, Mrs Dorothy |
Opposed |
|
| Bulimba |
ALP |
Purcell, Mr Patrick |
Opposed |
|
| Mansfield |
ALP |
Reeves, Mr Philip |
Supported |
|
| Mudgeeraba |
ALP |
Reilly, Mrs Dianne |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Townsville |
ALP |
Reynolds, Hon Michael |
[Speaker] |
|
| Lockyer |
LNP |
Rickuss, Mr Ian |
Supported |
|
| Nudgee |
ALP |
Roberts, Hon Neil |
Supported |
|
| Stretton |
ALP |
Robertson, Hon Stephen |
Supported |
|
| Rockhampton |
ALP |
Schwarten, Hon Robert |
Supported |
|
| Woodridge |
ALP |
Scott, Mrs Desley |
Supported |
|
| Callide |
LNP |
Seeney, Mr Jeffrey |
Supported |
|
| Toowoomba North |
ALP |
Shine, Hon Kerry |
Opposed |
|
| Maroochydore |
LNP |
Simpson, Ms Fiona |
Opposed |
|
| Burleigh |
ALP |
Smith, Mrs Christine |
Opposed |
|
| Mount Gravatt |
ALP |
Spence, Hon Ms Judith |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Southern Downs |
LNP |
Springborg, Mr Lawrence |
Opposed |
|
| Robina |
LNP |
Stevens, Mr Raymond |
Supported |
|
| Springwood |
ALP |
Stone, Ms Barbara |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Algester |
ALP |
Struthers, Ms Karen |
Supported |
Yes (2006) |
| Currumbin |
LNP |
Stuckey, Mrs Janet |
Supported |
|
| Pumicestone |
ALP |
Sullivan, Mrs Carryn |
Supported |
|
| Redcliffe |
ALP |
van Litsenburg, Ms Elisabeth |
Opposed |
|
| Thuringowa |
ALP |
Wallace, Hon Craig |
Absent |
|
| Cleveland |
ALP |
Weightman, Mr Phillip |
Absent |
|
| Everton |
ALP |
Welford, Hon Rodney |
Absent |
|
| Nicklin |
IND |
Wellington, Mr Peter |
Opposed |
|
| Murrumba |
ALP |
Wells, Hon Dean |
Supported |
|
| Ipswich West |
ALP |
Wendt, Mr Wayne |
Supported |
|
| Barron River |
ALP |
Wettenhall, Mr Stephen |
Supported |
|
| Ferny Grove |
ALP |
Wilson, Hon Geoffrey |
Opposed |
|
EMILY's List
EMILY's List is a political network formed to increase the number of women Labor parliamentarians who are willing to support key feminist issues, including abortion. It provides financial, political and personal support to Labor women candidates who agree to support the values of EMILY's List. It is the only network of its kind in Australian politics. |
EMILY's List members and candidates must support the principles of equity, diversity, pro-choice, and the provision of equal pay and childcare, both in the community and in Parliament. Many of these are significant issues but it is concerning that membership of such a network dictates a parliamentarian's vote. For example, EMILY's List members consistently support pro-abortion policies, reflecting both their personal beliefs and their membership of the List. Without exception, every Federal ALP parliamentarian named on EMILY's List voted to support the abortion drug RU486 and to permit the cloning of human embryos for destructive research. |
 |
Click here for the list of endorsed Emily’s List candidates in the Queensland election.
|
|
What the Parties think
|
Poverty and Justice
Alcohol abuse // Poker machines // Homelessness and housing affordability // Charter of rights // Prostitution
|
Life
Abortion and the law // Abortion statistics // Surrogacy // Euthanasia // Palliative care
|
Family
Adoption // Family policy // Civil partnerships
|
|